Plan to tax monster utes, SUVs into oblivion in Melbourne and Sydney

Tremendous-sized American-style pick-up vans and SUVs may very well be charged increased parking charges by some councils below plans to tax the controversial automobiles off metropolis roads.

Vehicles just like the Ford F-150 and the RAM 1500 have exploded in reputation in Australia in recent times, sparking backlash from some motorists who say the outsized automobiles are clogging roads and parking areas not designed for them.

This week, Yarra Metropolis Council in Melbourne will vote on a movement by Greens councillor Sophie Wade to analyze “methods to make travelling on Yarra’s streets extra equitable and discourage massive and heavy automobiles on Yarra’s streets, together with by contemplating proportionate parking charges primarily based on a automobile’s dimension”.

“Children are eight instances extra prone to die when hit by a SUV in comparison with a traditional passenger automobile,” the movement says.

“Bigger automobiles are extra polluting and have a better local weather impression. If SUVs had been a rustic, they’d rank because the sixth most polluting on the earth.”

NSW Greens transport spokeswoman Cate Faehrmann advised The Sydney Morning Herald on Saturday that “the scale of SUVs is getting ridiculous” and backed measures to discourage their use when not required for real work.

“Huge SUVs are taking over much more highway area, together with after they’re parked, so if increased parking charges make just a few drivers catch the practice or experience their bike as an alternative then deliver it on,” she advised the newspaper.

Randwick Greens Mayor Philipa Veitch advised The Sydney Morning Herald she was open to all choices to discourage outsized SUVs which “are clogging up our roads and are a menace for pedestrians and cyclists”.

However the Metropolis of Sydney stated it had no plans to lift parking charges on greater automobiles, and Woollahra Greens councillor Nicola Grieve advised the newspaper that whereas huge automobiles had been an issue “any enhance in parking charges should embody triggers to scale back CO2 emissions” as “basing a cost on weight alone will perversely discourage the change to EVs as they’re heavier resulting from their batteries”.

Final month, Parisians voted to triple the price of parking for SUVs in comparison with standard-sized automobiles, from €6 ($9.90) an hour within the metropolis centre to €18 ($29.70).

The value will increase, backed by 54.6 per cent of residents, will apply to automobiles with combustion or hybrid engines weighing greater than 1.6 tonnes and electrical automobiles weighing greater than two tonnes.

David Mepham, an city entry guide and writer of the guide Rethinking Parking, advised he may see benefit within the Paris transfer.

“Different cities are paying very shut consideration to this,” he stated.

“SUVs are literally a few of the most unsafe automobiles on the highway for pedestrians with a fatality fee that’s considerably increased than different automobiles.”

Final yr, Requirements Australia proposed growing the size of off-street parking areas by 20 centimetres, from 5.4 metres to five.6 metres, to suit Australia’s more and more greater automobiles.

The usual dimension of automobile areas on streets and in parking tons has been 5.4 metres lengthy and a couple of.4 metres to 2.6 metres large, sufficient to suit passenger automobiles and lightweight business automobiles, together with utes.

A 2023 mannequin Toyota HiLux can squeeze right into a present customary carpark with 7.5 centimetres to spare, lengthwise, however the RAM 1500 overhangs by 43 centimetres. In a 2.4-metre large carpark, a RAM’s width overhangs, too.

The proposed further 20 centimetres will solely halve the RAM’s overhang.

Critics of imported American-style vans slammed the proposal, arguing in opposition to any adjustments to Australian streets to accommodate greater automobiles.

“A part of our huge concern with the Requirements Australia proposal is that it codifies a worrying pattern of [making] bigger and bigger automobiles,” Jonathan O’Brien, lead organiser at YIMBY Melbourne, stated final yr.

“Realistically, it could simply be a 3 to 4 per cent discount in parks. So not an enormous distinction materially, nevertheless it’s codifying a pattern of accommodating vans that take up extra infrastructure.”

Mr O’Brien stated he was “firmly of the idea that these automobiles ought to be taxed out of existence”.

Paul Maric, co-founder of, earlier this yr determined to see what all of the fuss was about, saying that he spent a month driving a “enormous American pick-up truck” — a 2024 Ford F-150 Lariat lengthy wheelbase — and “beloved it”.

“What I discovered most fascinating was how upset some individuals obtained on the considered the automobile present and being round them, together with the idea that the individual driving it’s driving it as a result of they wish to annoy different drivers on the highway,” he wrote.

“The glares from onlookers had been paired with one older Tesla-driving bloke asking, ‘Do you actually have to be driving that factor? Have you learnt how a lot injury that does to the roads?’, as if I wanted a signed permission slip from him to choose the automobile I wished to drive.”

Richard Denniss, govt director of the Australia Institute assume tank, final month referred to as for a crackdown on “costly, inefficient and harmful” twin-cab utes and enormous SUVs, which he stated had soared in reputation resulting from beneficiant tax breaks.

“Economics 101 says we must always tax issues we would like fewer of and subsidise issues we would like extra of, however in Australia we subsidise the acquisition of twin-cab utes and cost items and providers tax on bikes and public transport,” Dr Denniss stated in an opinion piece for The Guardian.

SUVs and lightweight business automobiles made up greater than three quarters of all new automobile gross sales in 2022, in accordance with the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI).

It comes amid ongoing debate in regards to the Albanese authorities’s proposed new carbon emissions requirements, slated to take impact subsequent yr, which carmakers and the federal opposition declare may drive up the worth of the most well-liked utes and SUVs.

Vitality Minister Chris Bowen and Infrastructure Minister Catherine King have repeatedly insisted that the New Automobile Effectivity Commonplace (NVES) won’t have an effect on value or availability.

“That hasn’t occurred wherever else on the earth, and why would it not occur in Australia?” Mr Bowen advised the ABC’s Insiders program on Sunday.

“Peter Dutton is arguing that Australians deserve much less selection and ought to be paying extra for extra petrol. He could make that argument if he needs. The federal government chooses to make the argument that it’s about time Australia catches up with the remainder of the world and offers Australians higher decisions.”

Figures compiled by the FCAI recommend the top-selling automobile in 2023, the Ford Ranger, would incur a penalty of $6150 below the proposed 2025 CO2 goal and by 2029 the identical automobile — assuming no effectivity enhancements in that point — would incur a penalty of $17,950.

A Tesla Mannequin Y, then again, would incur a carbon credit score of $15,390 below the brand new guidelines, in accordance with the FCAI’s modelling.

Tesla final week introduced it was withdrawing from the trade physique over its public feedback in opposition to the brand new emissions requirements, with fellow electrical carmaker Polestar following swimsuit.

[email protected]

— with Michelle Bowes

Learn associated matters:MelbourneSydney

Related posts

New 12 months’s Eve climate forecast, BOM warnings, energy outages, storms


2024 Aston Martin Vantage revealed


Matt Campbell, Porsche win Rolex Daytona 24 hour


A Complete Information to Safeguard Your Digital Footprint


A Rogue Bot or a Glimpse into the Future?


Nationwide climate: Heatwave to hit NSW, SA, Victoria, Tasmania